|Scoreboard for Thurs. April 17, 2008|
|Total Viewers (million)||10.75||9.36||7.64||4.79||2.79|
|/Share: Adults 18-49||3.0/9||2.8/8||3.4/10||1.5/4||1.1/3|
CBS won the night in terms of total viewers with: Micronesia and repeats of and Without a Trace and FOX was in second overall with its game shows, Are You Smarter than a 5th Grader and Don't Forget the Lyrics. But FOX finished second overall and third in the 18-49 demo. CBS finished second in the demo and the peacocks at NBC cans puff their feathers way, way out there today with a convincing win in the 18-49 demo (albeit against no real competition on CBS other than , and none on ABC at all).
I'm going to absolutely ignore any comments in this post today, but it is time for Marc Berman to get a clue -- at least a little bit of a clue and then go back to enjoying. Berman notes a couple of things: one that will never be a breakout hit. That's probably true, actually, but where else can you get lines along the lines of "Save it for your iVillage blog, Lemon!"?
Of course Berman said something very similar breakout hit wise just a couple of weeks ago about The. OK, he said the exact.same.thing about The .
Now if the standard is, sure The is never going to be a breakout hit. But if the standard is about as many viewers as Deal or No Deal and having more than twice as many viewers in the 18-49 demo - then I'd call it a straight-up hit. The , with more than 9.8 million viewers and a 4.9/13 in the 18-49 demographic led NBC to a nightly win in the demo. In terms of the demo it is a breakout hit.
I have no problem at all for Marc's bias to not likeand explain why. That's fair. But to not judge a show based on its numbers is folly. And a 4.9 in the demo *is* a breakout hit. was certainly at an advantage last night because there was still no new 's , and was a repeat. Its demo performance will erode when 's comes back, but whether you love or hate it, you have to love, love, love those numbers.
That said, I am sort of with Berman when it comes to Eli Stone, which Marc thinks we've seen the last of. Repeats of LOST probably wasn't the best lead-in, but no matter. The real problem for Eli is that without its live plus seven days of DVR usage numbers, it stinks it up in the 18-49 demo. I won't be surprised if ABC cancels it, nor will I be surprised if they keep it and give it another try. The show is cute, the ratings are not. It's certainly on the bubble, the only question is whether the bubble has burst. We won't have to wait much longer to find out.
With no real competition to speak of, NBC's (soon to be ABC's?) Scrubs also had a very solid performance in the 18-49 demographic with a 3.7/10 in the demo at 9:30pm.
See Thursday night's full details:
|Time||Network||Show||Viewers (Millons)||18-49 Rating/Share||HH Rating|
|FOX||Are You Smarter Than a 5th Grader||9.19||2.5/8||5.6|
|NBC||My Name is Earl||6.77||2.6/9||4.5|
|FOX||Don't Forget the Lyrics||9.53||3.2/9||6.1|
|10:00||CBS||Without a Trace (Repeat)||9.47||2.4/7||7.1|
Nielsen Ratings Source: Nielsen Media Research. Full night's results available via Marc Berman/Mediaweek.
|Looking to purchase a new DVD player or one of the many new LCD TVs available? Check out this online shopping site and browse all of our electronics and televisions today!|