Our readers (and me among them, I had Hellcats), completely blew choosing Lone Star as the first broadcast cancellation of the season, only 5 shows received fewer votes than Lone Star. However, the second cancellation of the season (My Generation) got the fourth most votes. (this poll was posted on 8/24/10, nearly a month prior to the season start)
Our readers were also a bit too optimistic on how long Lone Star would last on Fox's schedule (it was pulled after 2 episodes). The poll was posted the Tuesday just after Lone Star's premiere ratings were known.
And, no surprise (to me), it was Dan LeBatard who topped our readers favorite PTI guest host by as good plurality. And after only his rookie week, Bill Simmons made a strong #2 showing.