Some folks have come to like playing "The Elimination Game" in our comments section for the Renew/Cancel Index posts, now you've got a post all your own to do it in.
If you're among the first people reading this post, and don't know how to play, hang on and I'm sure someone will explain it in the comments soon enough.
Go for it!
12/9 Update: This post has reached the 60 day limit for coments on our posts, so I created a new post here:
You guys forgot to put Beauty and the Beast! (not that it would have been missed)
NIKITA – 27 (-2)
GOSSIP GIRL – 22
HART OF DIXIE – 25 (+3)
EMILY OWENS, MD – 24 (+1)
90210 – 23
SUPERNATURAL – 26 (-3)
ARROW – 31 (+2)
THE VAMPIRE DIARIES – 22 (-1)
BEAUTY AND THE BEAST – 25
“Cute outfit. Did you join a gang?”
- Lemon, Hart of Dixie episode 1.02, “Parades and Paraiahs”
Commenter “Just Looking”‘s Fox changes have to be disregarded becasue he did an extra -3. The new totals are:
FOX
FRINGE – 32
THE MOB DOCTOR – 24
RAISING HOPE – 29
BEN AND KATE – 28
THE MINDY PROJECT – 24
THE CLEVELAND SHOW – 26
BONES – 29
BOB’S BURGERS – 25
AMERICAN DAD – 23
GLEE – 17
NEW GIRL – 19
FAMILY GUY – 23
THE SIMPSONS – 26
The Big Bang Theory should’t be included in the game if it’s already renewed
just checking this is for shows we like, not ones we think will be renewed or not? if so
FRINGE – 35 (+3)
THE MOB DOCTOR – 24
RAISING HOPE – 30 (+1)
BEN AND KATE – 30 (+2)
THE MINDY PROJECT – 24
THE CLEVELAND SHOW – 25 (-1)
BONES – 29
BOB’S BURGERS – 25
AMERICAN DAD – 21 (-2)
GLEE – 17
NEW GIRL – 19
FAMILY GUY – 23
THE SIMPSONS – 23 (-3)
CBS totals
MADE IN JERSEY – 24 (-1)
CSI: NY – 25
BLUE BLOODS – 25
THE GOOD WIFE – 23
THE MENTALIST – 28 (+1)
HAWAII FIVE-0 – 25
PARTNERS – 23 (-2)
VEGAS – 25
CSI – 22 (-3)
ELEMENTARY – 28 (+2)
PERSON OF INTEREST – 25
MIKE & MOLLY – 25
CRIMINAL MINDS – 24
NCIS: LOS ANGELES – 25
HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER – 22
TWO AND A HALF MEN – 25
2 BROKE GIRLS – 25
NCIS – 31 (+3)
THE BIG BANG THEORY – 25
NBC
ANIMAL PRACTICE – 23 (-2)
UP ALL NIGHT – 20 (-3)
30 ROCK – 28 (+1)
GUYS WITH KIDS – 25
GRIMM – 26
PARKS & RECREATION – 25
PARENTHOOD – 25
THE NEW NORMAL – 25
LAW & ORDER: SVU – 25
THE OFFICE – 25 (+2)
GO ON – 24 (-1)
REVOLUTION – 29 (+3)
ABC
PRIVATE PRACTICE – 25
666 PARK AVENUE – 25
APARTMENT 23 – 22 (-3)
CASTLE – 28 (+3)
LAST RESORT – 27 (+1)
HAPPY ENDINGS – 25
SCANDAL – 23 (-1)
LAST MAN STANDING – 25
THE MIDDLE – 25
THE NEIGHBORS – 18 (-2)
REVENGE – 25
SUBURGATORY – 25
ONCE UPON A TIME – 28
NASHVILLE – 25
GREY’S ANATOMY – 24
MODERN FAMILY – 30 (+2)
FOX
FRINGE – 35
THE MOB DOCTOR – 24
RAISING HOPE – 27 (-3)
BEN AND KATE – 28 (-2)
THE MINDY PROJECT – 23 (-1)
THE CLEVELAND SHOW – 25
BONES – 29
BOB’S BURGERS – 26 (+1)
AMERICAN DAD – 23 (+2)
GLEE – 17
NEW GIRL – 19
FAMILY GUY – 26 (+3)
THE SIMPSONS – 23
CBS
MADE IN JERSEY – 22 (-2)
CSI: NY – 25
BLUE BLOODS – 25
THE GOOD WIFE – 22 (-1)
THE MENTALIST – 28
HAWAII FIVE-0 – 27 (+2)
PARTNERS – 20 (-3)
VEGAS – 25
CSI – 22
ELEMENTARY – 28
PERSON OF INTEREST – 28 (+3)
MIKE & MOLLY – 25
CRIMINAL MINDS – 25 (+1)
NCIS: LOS ANGELES – 25
HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER – 22
TWO AND A HALF MEN – 25
2 BROKE GIRLS – 25
NCIS – 31
THE BIG BANG THEORY – 25
@Nick: Thanks for that.
@Emily: Yes, this is just for the shows you like, not the ones you think will be canceled.
CBS *Emily had the wrong totals so here are the new one’s with both hers & my votes!
MADE IN JERSEY – 19 (-2)
CSI: NY – 29
BLUE BLOODS – 25
THE GOOD WIFE – 20 (-1)
THE MENTALIST – 28
HAWAII FIVE-0 – 29 (+2)
PARTNERS – 17 (-3)
VEGAS – 23
CSI – 24
ELEMENTARY – 26
PERSON OF INTEREST – 29 (+3)
MIKE & MOLLY – 26
CRIMINAL MINDS – 25 (+1)
NCIS: LOS ANGELES – 25
HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER – 24
TWO AND A HALF MEN – 21
2 BROKE GIRLS – 24
NCIS – 33
THE BIG BANG THEORY – 28
* Again, Emily had the wrong totals so here are the new one’s with both her & my votes!
ABC
PRIVATE PRACTICE – 24 (-1)
666 PARK AVENUE – 25
APARTMENT 23 – 22 (-3)
CASTLE – 31 (+3)
LAST RESORT – 27 (-2)
HAPPY ENDINGS – 25
SCANDAL – 23 (-2)
LAST MAN STANDING – 25
THE MIDDLE – 25
THE NEIGHBORS – 18
REVENGE – 26 (+1)
SUBURGATORY – 25
ONCE UPON A TIME – 28
NASHVILLE – 25
GREY’S ANATOMY – 26 (+2)
MODERN FAMILY – 30 (+2)
FOX redo (No extra -3′s this time)
FOX
FRINGE – 35
THE MOB DOCTOR – 24
RAISING HOPE – 27
BEN AND KATE – 25 (-3)
THE MINDY PROJECT – 23
THE CLEVELAND SHOW – 25
BONES – 27 (-2)
BOB’S BURGERS – 25 (-1)
AMERICAN DAD – 23
GLEE – 20 (+3)
NEW GIRL – 22 (+2)
FAMILY GUY – 26
THE SIMPSONS – 24 (+1)
ABC
PRIVATE PRACTICE – 24
666 PARK AVENUE – 26 (+1)
APARTMENT 23 – 22
CASTLE – 33 (+2)
LAST RESORT – 30 (+3)
HAPPY ENDINGS – 23 (-2)
SCANDAL – 23
LAST MAN STANDING – 25
THE MIDDLE – 25
THE NEIGHBORS – 18
REVENGE – 23 (-3)
SUBURGATORY – 25
ONCE UPON A TIME – 28
NASHVILLE – 25
GREY’S ANATOMY – 25 (-1)
MODERN FAMILY – 30
From Last Resort 1.02 “Blue on Blue” -
Kylie: I could give you a lap dance right her and no one would notice today.
Linus: I would.
CBS *Even though MiJ has now been officially cancelled, it will stay in the game until it either wins or is eliminated.
MADE IN JERSEY – 19
CSI: NY – 29
BLUE BLOODS – 25
THE GOOD WIFE – 18 (-2)
THE MENTALIST – 30 (+2)
HAWAII FIVE-0 – 29
PARTNERS – 17
VEGAS – 23
CSI – 24
ELEMENTARY – 26
PERSON OF INTEREST – 29
MIKE & MOLLY – 26
CRIMINAL MINDS – 24 (-1)
NCIS: LOS ANGELES – 25
HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER – 21 (-3)
TWO AND A HALF MEN – 22 (+1)
2 BROKE GIRLS – 24
NCIS – 36 (+3)
THE BIG BANG THEORY – 28
From NCIS 10.03 “Phoenix” -
Palmer: Ducky yelled at me today!
CW
NIKITA – 28 (+1)
GOSSIP GIRL – 19 (-3)
HART OF DIXIE – 25
EMILY OWENS, MD – 24
90210 – 23
SUPERNATURAL – 29 (+3)
ARROW – 33 (+2)
THE VAMPIRE DIARIES – 20 (-2)
BEAUTY AND THE BEAST – 24 (-1)
From Angel 2.11 “Redefinition” -
Cordelia: What just happened? Can someone explain to me what just happened here?
Wesley: I believe we were fired.
Gunn: Canned.
Wesley: Let go.
Gunn: Axed.
Wesley: Shown the door.
Gunn: Booted.
Cordelia: All right! I get it. But…what just…happened?
FOX
FRINGE – 38 (+3)
THE MOB DOCTOR – 24
RAISING HOPE – 29 (+2)
BEN AND KATE – 25
THE MINDY PROJECT – 23
THE CLEVELAND SHOW – 25
BONES – 28 (+1)
BOB’S BURGERS – 25
AMERICAN DAD – 23
GLEE – 17 (-3)
NEW GIRL – 20 (-2)
FAMILY GUY – 25 (-1)
THE SIMPSONS – 24
From Dark Angel 1.01 “Pilot” -
Max: America really thought they had it dialed in, money hanging out the butt. But it was all just a bunch of ones and zeroes in a computer someplace. So, when that bomb went kablooey and the electromagnetic pulse turned all the ones and zeros into plain old zeroes, everyone’s like, “No way!” Now, America’s just another broke ex-super power looking for a handout and wondering why.
Damn, no good on this vote. Let me try again:
NBC
ANIMAL PRACTICE – 23
UP ALL NIGHT – 20
30 ROCK – 30 (+2)
GUYS WITH KIDS – 25
GRIMM – 26
PARKS & RECREATION – 24 (-1)
PARENTHOOD – 25
THE NEW NORMAL – 23 (-2)
LAW & ORDER: SVU – 25
THE OFFICE – 25
GO ON – 25 (+1)
REVOLUTION – 32 (+3)
From Go On 1.06 “Big League Chew” -
George: Here you go, grief eater. (hands Ryan his keys)
FOX
FRINGE – 40 (+2)
THE MOB DOCTOR – 24 (-2)
RAISING HOPE – 29
BEN AND KATE – 25
THE MINDY PROJECT – 23
THE CLEVELAND SHOW – 25
BONES – 31 (+3)
BOB’S BURGERS – 25
AMERICAN DAD – 22 (-1)
GLEE – 14 (-3)
NEW GIRL – 21 (+1)
FAMILY GUY – 25
THE SIMPSONS – 24
Bones 5×16 “The Parts in the Sum of the Whole”
Brennan: We were feeling each other up, like a honeymoon period.
Booth: Out. We were feeling each other out.
Had a case of the dumbs…all better now
FOX
FRINGE – 40 (+2)
THE MOB DOCTOR – 22 (-2)
RAISING HOPE – 29
BEN AND KATE – 25
THE MINDY PROJECT – 23
THE CLEVELAND SHOW – 25
BONES – 31 (+3)
BOB’S BURGERS – 25
AMERICAN DAD – 22 (-1)
GLEE – 14 (-3)
NEW GIRL – 21 (+1)
FAMILY GUY – 25
THE SIMPSONS – 24