'The Voice' vs. 'Survivor' vs. 'X-Factor': Who Will Win Tonight? (Poll)

Categories: Broadcast TV

Written By

November 7th, 2012

Update: The Voice did beat X-Factor and Survivor, but maybe next time we should include The Middle on this list...in came in a solid #2, beating both X Factor and Survivor. For more, see the overnight report.

Because of election night coverage, The Voice has been moved to Wednesday this week, putting it back in direct competition with X-Factor for the third time this season (the first was an early audition special, and the second time was during an out-of-pattern airing of X Factor). The first two times, The Voice triumphed, but will it still be a ratings juggernaut when you add Survivor to the mix? Could the "talent" audience be split with X-Factor and Voice going up against each other and automatically hand Survivor the win? Cast your vote  and tell us why in the comments.


  • F.

    The Voice 4.0
    The X-Factor 2.5
    Survivor 2.4

    Modern Family will probably win the night anyway

  • Kaylie

    I’ll be watching X Factor, but I say Modern Family.

  • SherLOCKED

    Voice wins. Its track record speaks for itself.

  • Flame

    Something else – Modern Family will win the head to head half hour and most likely the night.

  • Samuel

    Voice wins tonight, X Factor barely squeaks out a victory tomorrow.

  • Chris

    I’m watching The Voice and South Park, will watch Survivor: Philippines and Modern Family online tomorrow.

  • Joe D

    Poor “The Middle” relegated to “something else.”

  • Max Vrany

    The Voice will win but if Survivor can stay steady I’ll call that a win for Survivor as well. The Voice might also be enough to put Survivor over X-Factor as well.

  • CBSviewer

    I will be watching Survivor so I hope it won’t go below a 2.5.

  • Colin

    Voice will win in the demo but I expect Survivor to win in total viewers. Unfortunately, The X Factor won’t stand a chance. I love it so much more than the Voice though. I love the X Factor live shows so much more than the ones of The Voice. Plus, Christina doesn’t care much about her people….hate that

  • ICBBsFuture

    I think The Voice but I think all of them will be down because they’re all against each other…it should be interesting! I’ve been waiting for this to happen. :)

  • SJ

    The Voice will win. The X Factor will lose to The Middle. :D

  • Ricardo

    I’m more interested in what will Chicago Fire do with a great lead-in…

  • merrranga

    hey, i tried to vote in your poll, but ‘those who don’t watch’ wasn’t an option…

  • Kyle

    WOW! You guys forgot about The Middle. Not cool. That show is REALLY underrated.

  • omabin

    i think modern family will win the night… In the reality shows competition… Voice>Survivor>X-Factor. It will be interesting if Fox executives really are getting mad with this and if they get their revenge with idol in spring

  • EatMorePez

    The Voice will win the 8:00 hour, but I’ll be watching Arrow.

  • Cj morton

    @Kyle- up against the competition, the middle really isn’t a factor. It’s nothing against the quality of the show. It just can’t compete with the voice and survivor.

  • ICBBsFuture

    @ Colin

    Christina doesn’t care about her people? you serious man? Britney sucks as a judge or coach and her comments all useless. All she says is “I love you and I like what you’re wearing”…the coaches of The Voice actually know what they’re talking about.

  • Jon23812

    The Voice – 4.6
    X-Factor – 2.1

© 2015 Tribune Digital Ventures