
This post has reached its 60 day comment limit, continue on here!
Some folks have come to like playing "The Elimination Game" in our comments section for the Renew/Cancel Index posts, now you've got a post all your own to do it in.
If you're among the first people reading this post, and don't know how to play, hang on and I'm sure someone will explain it in the comments soon enough.
Go for it!










Basic Cable
COUGAR TOWN – 69 (+1)
PERCEPTION – 20 (+3)
THE AMERICANS – 30 (-3)
CONTINUUM – 49 (+2)
PSYCH – 42 (-2)
THE WALKING DEAD – 43 (-1)
AMERICAN HORROR STORY – 33
FALLING SKIES – 13
WAREHOUSE 13 – 24
DOCTOR WHO – 12
RIZZOLI & ISLES – 42
Premium Cable:
DEXTER – 49 (-2)
GAME OF THRONES – 71 (-1)
TORCHWOOD – 40 (-3)
HOMELAND – 69 (+2)
THE NEWSROOM – 44 (+3)
CURB YOUR ENTHUSIASM – 40
THE BORGIAS – 18 (+1)
CALIFORNICATION – 14
EPISODES – 30
80s:
CHEERS – 42
21 JUMP STREET – 42 (-2)
STAR TREK TNG – 35 (+2)
M*A*S*H – 15 (+3)
THE A-TEAM – 18 (-3)
90s:
SEINFELD – 27 (+2)
THE X-FILES – 27 (-3)
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER – 69 (-2)
EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND – 29 (+3)
00s:
FIREFLY – 16
SCRUBS – 25
PUSHING DAISIES – 12
Victors’ Village: Lost
10s:
FRINGE – 79
TERRA NOVA – 24 (+3)
CHUCK – 52 (-3)
80s:
CHEERS – 42
21 JUMP STREET – 45 (+3)
STAR TREK TNG – 37 (+2)
M*A*S*H – 12 (-3)
THE A-TEAM – 16 (-2)
90s:
SEINFELD – 25 (-2)
THE X-FILES – 29 (+2)
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER – 72 (+3)
EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND – 26 (-3)
00s:
FIREFLY – 16
SCRUBS – 28 (+3)
PUSHING DAISIES – 9 (-3)
Victors’ Village: Lost
10s:
FRINGE – 82 (+3)
TERRA NOVA – 21 (-3)
CHUCK – 52
Basic Cable
COUGAR TOWN – 72 (+3)
PERCEPTION – 21 (+1)
THE AMERICANS – 30
CONTINUUM – 46 (-3)
PSYCH – 42
THE WALKING DEAD – 45 (+2)
AMERICAN HORROR STORY – 33
FALLING SKIES – 13
WAREHOUSE 13 – 24
DOCTOR WHO – 11 (-1)
RIZZOLI & ISLES – 40 (-2)
Premium Cable:
DEXTER – 49
GAME OF THRONES – 74 (+3)
TORCHWOOD – 40
HOMELAND – 70 (+1)
THE NEWSROOM – 46 (+2)
CURB YOUR ENTHUSIASM – 38 (-2)
THE BORGIAS – 18
CALIFORNICATION – 11 (-3)
EPISODES – 29 (-1)
NBC
1600 PENN – 7 (-3)
COMMUNITY – 93 (+2)
30 ROCK – 40
GO ON – 48 (-2)
SMASH – 13 (+1)
PARKS & REC – 64 (+3)
GRIMM – 19
PARENTHOOD – 28
THE OFFICE – 17 (-1)
CHICAGO FIRE – 24
Victors’ Village – Revolution
Fox
THE MINDY PROJECT – 27 (+2)
TOUCH – 40 (-3)
BONES – 26 (-1)
BOB’S BURGERS – 35 (+1)
THE SIMPSONS – 27 (-2)
THE FOLLOWING – 43 (+3)
Victors’ Village – Raising Hope
CW
NIKITA – 65 (+2)
HART OF DIXIE – 4 (-2)
SUPERNATURAL – 75 (-3)
ARROW – 81 (+3)
CBS
BLUE BLOODS – 10
CSI: NY – 18 (-2)
THE GOOD WIFE – 25
RULES OF ENGAGEMENT – 10
THE MENTALIST – 36 (+1)
CSI – 25
ELEMENTARY – 13 (-1)
NCIS: LA – 13
MIKE & MOLLY – 35 (-3)
NCIS – 41 (+2)
HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER – 28 (+3)
Victors’ Village: Person of Interest, TBBT
ABC
BODY OF PROOF – 3 (-3)
ONCE UPON A TIME – 82 (+3)
MODERN FAMILY – 68
Victors’ Village – The Middle, Castle
ABC
BODY OF PROOF – 0 (-3) Down and out.
ONCE UPON A TIME – 82
MODERN FAMILY – 71 (+3)
Victors’ Village – The Middle, Castle
Since OUAT and Modern Family have over 100 points between them, the next ABC vote will start the Winners’ Circle with both those shows (plus The Middle and Castle) reset to 10 points each.
CBS
BLUE BLOODS – 9 (-1)
CSI: NY – 18
THE GOOD WIFE – 25
RULES OF ENGAGEMENT – 8 (-2)
THE MENTALIST – 38 (+2)
CSI – 25
ELEMENTARY – 14 (+1)
NCIS: LA – 13
MIKE & MOLLY – 35
NCIS – 44 (+3)
HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER – 25 (-3)
Victors’ Village: PoI, TBBT
CW
NIKITA – 67 (+2)
HART OF DIXIE – 1 (-3)
SUPERNATURAL – 78 (+3)
ARROW – 79 (-2)
Fox
THE MINDY PROJECT – 24 (-3)
TOUCH – 43 (+3)
BONES – 28 (+2)
BOB’S BURGERS – 34 (-1)
THE SIMPSONS – 28 (+1)
THE FOLLOWING – 41 (-2)
Victors’ Village – Raising Hope
NBC
1600 PENN – 8 (+1)
COMMUNITY – 96 (+3)
30 ROCK – 40
GO ON – 48
SMASH – 11 (-2)
PARKS & REC – 61 (-3)
GRIMM – 21 (+2)
PARENTHOOD – 28
THE OFFICE – 16 (-1)
CHICAGO FIRE – 24
Victors’ Village – Revolution
Basic Cable
COUGAR TOWN – 74 (+2)
PERCEPTION – 18 (-3)
THE AMERICANS – 28 (-1)
CONTINUUM – 46
PSYCH – 42
THE WALKING DEAD – 44 (-1)
AMERICAN HORROR STORY – 33
FALLING SKIES – 13
WAREHOUSE 13 – 24
DOCTOR WHO – 12 (+1)
RIZZOLI & ISLES – 43 (+3)
Premium Cable:
DEXTER – 52 (+3)
GAME OF THRONES – 75 (+1)
TORCHWOOD – 42 (+2)
HOMELAND – 70
THE NEWSROOM – 43 (-3)
CURB YOUR ENTHUSIASM – 38
THE BORGIAS – 17 (-1)
CALIFORNICATION – 11
EPISODES – 27 (-2)
80s:
CHEERS – 40 (-2)
21 JUMP STREET – 48 (+3)
STAR TREK TNG – 39 (+2)
M*A*S*H – 9 (-3)
THE A-TEAM – 16
90s:
SEINFELD – 23 (-2)
THE X-FILES – 31 (+2)
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER – 75 (+3)
EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND – 23 (-3)
00s:
FIREFLY – 16
SCRUBS – 25 (-3)
PUSHING DAISIES – 12 (+3)
Victors’ Village: Lost
10s:
FRINGE – 85 (+3)
TERRA NOVA – 21
CHUCK – 49 (-3)
@Ricky, glad you’re enjoying Cougar Town. One of my favorites. I have all the dvds.
80s:
CHEERS – 43 (+3)
21 JUMP STREET – 45 (-3)
STAR TREK TNG – 37 (-2)
M*A*S*H – 11 (+2)
THE A-TEAM – 16
90s:
SEINFELD – 25 (+2)
THE X-FILES – 29 (-2)
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER – 72 (-3)
EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND – 26 (+3)
00s:
FIREFLY – 16
SCRUBS – 28 (+3)
PUSHING DAISIES – 9 (-3)
Victors’ Village: Lost
10s:
FRINGE – 85
TERRA NOVA – 18 (-3)
CHUCK – 52 (+3)
from Cheers 3.19:
Diane: Oh, not this again. It’s starting to sound like a broken record.
Frasier: Oh, now you’re saying that I’m redundant, that I repeat myself, that I say things over and over!
Basic Cable
COUGAR TOWN – 76 (+2)
PERCEPTION – 15 (-3)
THE AMERICANS – 27 (-1)
CONTINUUM – 46
PSYCH – 45 (+3)
THE WALKING DEAD – 45 (+1)
AMERICAN HORROR STORY – 33
FALLING SKIES – 13
WAREHOUSE 13 – 24
DOCTOR WHO – 10 (-2)
RIZZOLI & ISLES – 43
Premium Cable:
DEXTER – 50 (-2)
GAME OF THRONES – 75
TORCHWOOD – 42
HOMELAND – 71 (+1)
THE NEWSROOM – 40 (-3)
CURB YOUR ENTHUSIASM – 41 (+3)
THE BORGIAS – 16 (-1)
CALIFORNICATION – 11
EPISODES – 29 (+2)
from Psych 3.5:
Shawn: The important thing is that you got your cover story.
Reporter: Actually, it’s page 64.
Shawn: It really depends on how you fold it, doesn’t it?
NBC
1600 PENN – 8
COMMUNITY – 99 (+3)
30 ROCK – 41 (+1)
GO ON – 48
SMASH – 9 (-2)
PARKS & REC – 63 (+2)
GRIMM – 21
PARENTHOOD – 28
THE OFFICE – 15 (-1)
CHICAGO FIRE – 21 (-3)
Victors’ Village – Revolution
quote from GO [1.11]:
Mr. K: Ryan, should we act on that whole “Sam and Diane” thing we’ve got going?
Ryan: Oh, I think the open-ended nature of that is part of what makes it special.
Fox
THE MINDY PROJECT – 27 (+3)
TOUCH – 40 (-3)
BONES – 27 (-1)
BOB’S BURGERS – 36 (+2)
THE SIMPSONS – 29 (+1)
THE FOLLOWING – 39 (-2)
Victors’ Village – Raising Hope
Out of Fox quotes again, so here’s one from NBC’s Parks [2.18]:
Evelyn: Well, Miss Knope. I have to say, I’m very disappointed.
Leslie: You didn’t HAVE to say that. You could have just thought it.
CW
NIKITA – 69 (+2)
HART OF DIXIE – 0 (-2) eliminated
SUPERNATURAL – 81 (+3)
ARROW – 77 (-2)
Next votes will be +3 and -3 only.
quote from SPN 5.14:
Dean: [speaking on his cell] Cas, it’s Dean. Yeah, Room 31-C, basement level, St. James Medical Center–
Castiel: [appears in front of Dean, still talking into the cell phone] I’m there now.
Dean: … yeah, I get that.
Castiel: I’m gonna hang up now.
Dean: …right.
ABC WINNERS CIRCLE
MODERN FAMILY – 7 (-3)
THE MIDDLE – 12 (+2)
ONCE UPON A TIME – 8 (-2)
CASTLE – 13 (+3)
from Castle 5.15:
Rick: He was hiding in plain sight. A foreign agent in deep cover on some kind of reconnaissance mission.
Kate: So then why would he shoot up a van?
Rick: Maybe Jack Bauer was driving.
^ Hope I did that right – I couldn’t remember if we did 3s and 2s when there are 4 in the winners circle.