This post has reached its 60 day comment limit, continue on here!
Some folks have come to like playing "The Elimination Game" in our comments section for the Renew/Cancel Index posts, now you've got a post all your own to do it in.
If you're among the first people reading this post, and don't know how to play, hang on and I'm sure someone will explain it in the comments soon enough.
Go for it!
80s:
CHEERS – 26
21 JUMP STREET – 27 (+3)
STAR TREK TNG – 23 (+2)
CAGNEY AND LACEY – 4
THE COSBY SHOW – 14
THE GOLDEN GIRLS – 13 (-3)
M*A*S*H – 15 (-1)
THE A-TEAM – 18 (+1)
MOONLIGHTING – 3 (-2)
KNIGHT RIDER – 9
90s:
SEINFELD – 26
FRIENDS – 7 (-3)
THE X-FILES – 25 (+2)
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER – 41 (+3)
FREAKS AND GEEKS – 9
TWIN PEAKS – 3 (+1)
EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND – 26 (-1)
ROSEANNE – 15 (-2)
00s:
LOST – 83 (+3)
FIREFLY – 17
SCRUBS – 23 (-3)
ANGEL – 8 (-2)
PUSHING DAISIES – 22 (+2)
10s:
FRINGE – 48 (+3)
TERRA NOVA – 22 (+2)
MISSING – 9 (-1)
ALCATRAZ – 16
LAST RESORT – 5 (+1)
CHUCK – 30
THE GOOD GUYS – 10 (-3)
ALPHAS – 2 (-2)
RUBICON – 10
80s:
CHEERS – 29 (+3)
21 JUMP STREET – 26
STAR TREK TNG – 22 (-1)
STAR TREK TNG – 23
CAGNEY AND LACEY – 2 (-2)
THE COSBY SHOW – 14
THE GOLDEN GIRLS – 15 (+2)
M*A*S*H – 16 (+1)
THE A-TEAM – 18
MOONLIGHTING – 0 (-3) eliminated
KNIGHT RIDER – 9
90s:
SEINFELD – 28 (+2)
FRIENDS – 6 (-1)
THE X-FILES – 25
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER – 41
FREAKS AND GEEKS – 7 (-2)
TWIN PEAKS – 0 (-3)
EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND – 29 (+3)
ROSEANNE – 16 (+1)
00s:
LOST – 86 (+3)
FIREFLY – 17
SCRUBS – 25 (+2)
ANGEL – 5 (-3)
PUSHING DAISIES – 20 (-2)
10s:
FRINGE – 48
TERRA NOVA – 22
MISSING – 6 (-3)
ALCATRAZ – 17 (+1)
LAST RESORT – 3 (-2)
CHUCK – 33 (+3)
THE GOOD GUYS – 12 (+2)
ALPHAS – 1 (-1)
RUBICON – 10
from Cheers 3.4:
Coach: Boy, Doc, you tell great stories.
Frasier: That was Poe.
Coach: Don’t be modest, it was great.
Premium Cable:
DEXTER – 39
GAME OF THRONES – 48
TORCHWOOD – 37
HOMELAND – 48 (+1)
THE NEWSROOM – 44
CURB YOUR ENTHUSIASM – 41 (+3)
BOARDWALK EMPIRE – 13 (-1)
SHAMELESS – 10
THE BORGIAS – 20 (-2)
CALIFORNICATION – 25
GIRLS – 3 (-3)
SPARTACUS – 16
EPISODES – 31 (+2)
Basic Cable:
COUGAR TOWN – 59 (+2)
PERCEPTION – 27 (-1)
THE AMERICANS – 39
CONTINUUM – 40
PSYCH – 34 (+3)
THE WALKING DEAD – 29
AMERICAN HORROR STORY – 26
FALLING SKIES – 19 (-2)
WAREHOUSE 13 – 24
DOCTOR WHO – 19 (-1)
BURN NOTICE – 20
RIZZOLI & ISLES – 37
HOT IN CLEVELAND – 3 (+1)
from Psych [3.7]:
Gus: I never thought I would hear you say that.
Shawn: Even more than “sinkhole sissy-feet flapjack go-go boots”?
NBC
THE NEW NORMAL – 11
1600 PENN – 19
COMMUNITY – 58 (+1)
30 ROCK – 47 (+2)
GUYS WITH KIDS – 11
GO ON – 33
DECEPTION – 16 (-1)
SMASH – 22
DO NO HARM – 12 (-2)
PARKS & REC – 48 (+3)
GRIMM – 23
PARENTHOOD – 31
THE OFFICE – 23
SVU – 9 (-3)
CHICAGO FIRE – 26
REVOLUTION – 64
from 30R 3.18:
Jenna: The Kids’ Choice Awards? Fine. I’ll set aside my feud with Raven Simone for one day, but she knows what she did.
FOX
THE MINDY PROJECT – 21 (+1)
TOUCH – 52
RAISING HOPE – 90 (+3)
NEW GIRL – 11 (+2)
BONES – 28
BOB’S BURGERS – 29
GLEE – 3 (-3)
THE SIMPSONS – 26 (-2)
THE FOLLOWING – 39 (-1)
from RH 3.16:
Burt: Which one of you is from NBC?
(An exec indicates himself and Burt then kicks him) That’s for cancelling “My Name is Earl”!
NBC Prez: That was eight network presidents ago! I loved it!
CW
EMILY OWENS – 10 (-2)
NIKITA – 63 (+2)
THE CARRIE DIARIES – 1 (-3)
HART OF DIXIE – 25 (-1)
SUPERNATURAL – 63 (+3)
ARROW – 63 (+1)
Wow, a 3-way tie right now between SPN (my fave), Nikita and Arrow.
Quote from SPN 7.14:
Dean: Shark Week, man. How do you not watch that? Whole week of sharks!
CBS
BLUE BLOODS – 20
CSI: NY – 26
VEGAS – 6
THE GOOD WIFE – 22
RULES OF ENGAGEMENT – 24 (+1)
THE MENTALIST – 27
CSI – 25
ELEMENTARY – 24
HAWAII FIVE-0 – 5 (-1)
NCIS: LA – 23
PERSON OF INTEREST – 67
MIKE & MOLLY – 35
NCIS – 38
HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER – 24 (+2)
2 BROKE GIRLS – 12 (-2)
TWO AND A HALF MEN – 6 (-3)
THE BIG BANG THEORY – 66 (+3)
I’m still out of CBS quotes, but here’s one from 30R on NBC from when Jenna and Tracy were playing CSI at Ken’s apartment (3.17):
Tracy: Jenna, I just want you to know that if we find any human remains in there, I’m gonna throw up all over your face.
ABC
HAPPY ENDINGS – 6
BODY OF PROOF – 30
LAST MAN STANDING – 19
CASTLE – 70 (+3)
THE NEIGHBORS – 19
NASHVILLE – 15 (-1)
SUBURGATORY – 17 (-2)
THE MIDDLE – 78 (+2)
ONCE UPON A TIME – 53
GREY’S ANATOMY – 0 (-3) finally eliminated
MODERN FAMILY – 39 (+1)
Out of ABC quotes for now, so here’s another 30R quote (3.1):
Jack: This is G.E.!
Devon: It’s just G now, Jack! I sold the E to Samsung. They’re Samesung now.
ABC
HAPPY ENDINGS – 6
BODY OF PROOF – 30
LAST MAN STANDING – 16 (-3)
CASTLE – 73 (+3)
THE NEIGHBORS – 18 (-1)
NASHVILLE – 15
SUBURGATORY – 15 (-2)
THE MIDDLE – 80 (+2)
ONCE UPON A TIME – 54 (+1)
MODERN FAMILY – 39
CBS
BLUE BLOODS – 20
CSI: NY – 26
VEGAS – 3 (-3)
THE GOOD WIFE – 22
RULES OF ENGAGEMENT – 24
THE MENTALIST – 27
CSI – 25
ELEMENTARY – 24
HAWAII FIVE-0 – 3 (-2)
NCIS: LA – 23
PERSON OF INTEREST – 68 (+1)
MIKE & MOLLY – 35
NCIS – 38
HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER – 26 (+2)
2 BROKE GIRLS – 11 (-1)
TWO AND A HALF MEN – 6
THE BIG BANG THEORY – 69 (+3)
CW
EMILY OWENS – 7 (-3)
NIKITA – 65 (+2)
THE CARRIE DIARIES – 0 (-1) Eliminated!
HART OF DIXIE – 26 (+1)
SUPERNATURAL – 61 (-2)
ARROW – 66 (+3)
From now on we will vote with +2,+3,-2,-3 on the CW game
FOX
THE MINDY PROJECT – 21
TOUCH – 49 (-3)
RAISING HOPE – 93 (+3)
NEW GIRL – 10 (-1)
BONES – 26 (-2)
BOB’S BURGERS – 30 (+1)
GLEE – 3
THE SIMPSONS – 26
THE FOLLOWING – 41 (+2)
NBC
THE NEW NORMAL – 9 (-2)
1600 PENN – 18 (-1)
COMMUNITY – 59 (+1)
30 ROCK – 47
GUYS WITH KIDS – 8 (-3)
GO ON – 33
DECEPTION – 16
SMASH – 22
DO NO HARM – 12
PARKS & REC – 51 (+3)
GRIMM – 23
PARENTHOOD – 31
THE OFFICE – 23
SVU – 9
CHICAGO FIRE – 26
REVOLUTION – 66 (+2)
Premium Cable:
DEXTER – 39
GAME OF THRONES – 51 (+3)
TORCHWOOD – 37
HOMELAND – 49 (+1)
THE NEWSROOM – 46 (+2)
CURB YOUR ENTHUSIASM – 40 (-1)
BOARDWALK EMPIRE – 13
SHAMELESS – 7 (-3)
THE BORGIAS – 20
CALIFORNICATION – 25
GIRLS – 3
SPARTACUS – 14 (-2)
EPISODES – 31
Basic Cable:
COUGAR TOWN – 61 (+2)
PERCEPTION – 27
THE AMERICANS – 42 (+3)
CONTINUUM – 39 (-1)
PSYCH – 34
THE WALKING DEAD – 30 (+1)
AMERICAN HORROR STORY – 26
FALLING SKIES – 19
WAREHOUSE 13 – 24
DOCTOR WHO – 19
BURN NOTICE – 18 (-2)
RIZZOLI & ISLES – 37
HOT IN CLEVELAND – 0 (-3) Eliminated
80s:
CHEERS – 29
21 JUMP STREET – 29 (+3)
STAR TREK TNG – 24 (+2)
CAGNEY AND LACEY – 0 (-2) Eliminated!
THE COSBY SHOW – 13 (-1)
THE GOLDEN GIRLS – 15
M*A*S*H – 16
THE A-TEAM – 19 (+1)
KNIGHT RIDER – 6 (-3)
90s:
SEINFELD – 27 (-1)
FRIENDS – 9 (+3)
THE X-FILES – 26 (+1)
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER – 43 (+2)
FREAKS AND GEEKS – 7
EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND – 27 (-2)
ROSEANNE – 13 (-3)
00s:
LOST – 89 (+3)
FIREFLY – 14 (-3)
SCRUBS – 27 (+2)
ANGEL – 5
PUSHING DAISIES – 18 (-2)
10s:
FRINGE – 50 (+2)
TERRA NOVA – 23 (+1)
MISSING – 6
ALCATRAZ – 15 (-2)
LAST RESORT – 0 (-3) Eliminated
CHUCK – 39 (+3)
THE GOOD GUYS – 12
ALPHAS – 0 (-1) Eliminated!
RUBICON – 10
ABC
HAPPY ENDINGS – 3 (-3)
BODY OF PROOF – 30
LAST MAN STANDING – 16
CASTLE – 76 (+3)
THE NEIGHBORS – 18
NASHVILLE – 13 (-2)
SUBURGATORY – 14 (-1)
THE MIDDLE – 82 (+2)
ONCE UPON A TIME – 54
MODERN FAMILY – 40 (+1)
CBS
BLUE BLOODS – 20
CSI: NY – 26
VEGAS – 3
THE GOOD WIFE – 22
RULES OF ENGAGEMENT – 23 (-1)
THE MENTALIST – 27
CSI – 25
ELEMENTARY – 24
HAWAII FIVE-0 – 4 (+1)
NCIS: LA – 23
PERSON OF INTEREST – 71 (+3)
MIKE & MOLLY – 35
NCIS – 40 (+2)
HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER – 23 (-3)
2 BROKE GIRLS – 9 (-2)
TWO AND A HALF MEN – 6
THE BIG BANG THEORY – 69
CW
EMILY OWENS – 4 (-3)
NIKITA – 67 (+2)
HART OF DIXIE – 24 (-2)
SUPERNATURAL – 64 (+3)
ARROW – 66
FOX
THE MINDY PROJECT – 20 (-1)
TOUCH – 52 (+3)
RAISING HOPE – 95 (+2)
NEW GIRL – 8 (-2)
BONES – 27 (+1)
BOB’S BURGERS – 30
GLEE – 0 (-3) Loss of autotune leads to a collective nervous breakdown.
THE SIMPSONS – 26
THE FOLLOWING – 41
NBC
THE NEW NORMAL – 6 (-3)
1600 PENN – 19 (+1)
COMMUNITY – 61 (+2)
30 ROCK – 47
GUYS WITH KIDS – 8
GO ON – 33
DECEPTION – 16
SMASH – 21 (-1)
DO NO HARM – 12
PARKS & REC – 49 (-2)
GRIMM – 23
PARENTHOOD – 31
THE OFFICE – 23
SVU – 9
CHICAGO FIRE – 26
REVOLUTION – 69 (+3)
Basic Cable:
COUGAR TOWN – 58 (-3)
PERCEPTION – 25 (-2)
THE AMERICANS – 41 (-1)
CONTINUUM – 41 (+2)
PSYCH – 34
THE WALKING DEAD – 30
AMERICAN HORROR STORY – 26
FALLING SKIES – 19
WAREHOUSE 13 – 24
DOCTOR WHO – 20 (+1)
BURN NOTICE – 18
RIZZOLI & ISLES – 40 (+3)
Premium Cable:
DEXTER – 42 (+3)
GAME OF THRONES – 52 (+1)
TORCHWOOD – 39 (+2)
HOMELAND – 49
THE NEWSROOM – 45 (-1)
CURB YOUR ENTHUSIASM – 40
BOARDWALK EMPIRE – 11 (-2)
SHAMELESS – 7
THE BORGIAS – 20
CALIFORNICATION – 25
GIRLS – 0 (-3) This was supposed to be a comedy?
SPARTACUS – 14
EPISODES – 31
80s:
CHEERS – 29
21 JUMP STREET – 32 (+3)
STAR TREK TNG – 26 (+2)
THE COSBY SHOW – 12 (-1)
THE GOLDEN GIRLS – 12 (-3)
M*A*S*H – 14 (-2)
THE A-TEAM – 20 (+1)
KNIGHT RIDER – 6
90s:
SEINFELD – 27
FRIENDS – 6 (-3)
THE X-FILES – 28 (+2)
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER – 46 (+3)
FREAKS AND GEEKS – 8 (+1)
EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND – 26 (-1)
ROSEANNE – 11 (-2)
00s:
LOST – 92 (+3)
FIREFLY – 14
SCRUBS – 24 (-3)
ANGEL – 3 (-2)
PUSHING DAISIES – 20 (+2)
10s:
FRINGE – 53 (+3)
TERRA NOVA – 25 (+2)
MISSING – 4 (-2)
ALCATRAZ – 16 (+1)
CHUCK – 39
THE GOOD GUYS – 9 (-3)
RUBICON – 9 (-1)
80s:
CHEERS – 32 (+3)
21 JUMP STREET – 29 (-3)
STAR TREK TNG – 24 (-2)
THE COSBY SHOW – 12
THE GOLDEN GIRLS – 14 (+2)
M*A*S*H – 15 (+1)
THE A-TEAM – 19 (-1)
KNIGHT RIDER – 6
90s:
SEINFELD – 30 (+3)
FRIENDS – 5 (-1)
THE X-FILES – 26 (-2)
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER – 46
FREAKS AND GEEKS – 5 (-3)
EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND – 28 (+2)
ROSEANNE – 12 (+1)
00s:
LOST – 95 (+3)
FIREFLY – 14
SCRUBS – 26 (+2)
ANGEL – 0 (-3) eliminated
PUSHING DAISIES – 18 (-2)
10s:
FRINGE – 51 (-2)
TERRA NOVA – 24 (-1)
MISSING – 1 (-3)
ALCATRAZ – 17 (+1)
CHUCK – 42 (+3)
THE GOOD GUYS – 11 (+2)
RUBICON – 9
from Cheers 7.9:
Sam: Sweetheart, I’ve handled trickier situations than this before. Remember the time I dated those lovely Henshaw triplets all at the same time.
Carla: Sammy, first of all, that was back when you were drinking like a fish, and second of all, that was one chick.