This post has reached its 60 day comment limit, continue on here!
Some folks have come to like playing "The Elimination Game" in our comments section for the Renew/Cancel Index posts, now you've got a post all your own to do it in.
If you're among the first people reading this post, and don't know how to play, hang on and I'm sure someone will explain it in the comments soon enough.
Go for it!
FOX
THE MINDY PROJECT – 22
TOUCH – 45 (-2)
NEW GIRL – 4 (+2)
BONES – 26 (-3)
BOB’S BURGERS – 33 (-1)
THE SIMPSONS – 26 (+1)
THE FOLLOWING – 43 (+3)
Victors’ Village: Raising Hope
NBC
1600 PENN – 14 (-2)
COMMUNITY – 76 (+1)
30 ROCK – 44
GUYS WITH KIDS – 2 (-1)
GO ON – 42 (+2)
DECEPTION – 11
SMASH – 17
DO NO HARM – 5
PARKS & REC – 55
GRIMM – 20
PARENTHOOD – 31
THE OFFICE – 20
SVU – 3 (-3) Eliminated
CHICAGO FIRE – 26
REVOLUTION – 90 (+3)
NBC
1600 PENN – 13 (-1)
COMMUNITY – 77 (+1)
30 ROCK – 44
GUYS WITH KIDS – 0 (-2) Eliminated!
GO ON – 42
DECEPTION – 11
SMASH – 17
DO NO HARM – 2 (-3)
PARKS & REC – 57 (+2)
GRIMM – 20
PARENTHOOD – 31
THE OFFICE – 20
CHICAGO FIRE – 26
REVOLUTION – 93 (+3)
FOX
THE MINDY PROJECT – 24 (+2)
TOUCH – 42 (-3)
NEW GIRL – 3 (-1)
BONES – 24 (-2)
BOB’S BURGERS – 33
THE SIMPSONS – 27 (+1)
THE FOLLOWING – 46 (+3)
Victors’ Village: Raising Hope
CW
NIKITA – 61 (+2)
HART OF DIXIE – 14 (-2)
SUPERNATURAL – 75 (-3)
ARROW – 75 (+3)
CBS
BLUE BLOODS – 14
CSI: NY – 19 (-2)
THE GOOD WIFE – 24
RULES OF ENGAGEMENT – 16
THE MENTALIST – 32
CSI – 25
ELEMENTARY – 17 (-1)
NCIS: LA – 18
PERSON OF INTEREST – 93 (+2)
MIKE & MOLLY – 35 (-3)
NCIS – 41
HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER – 25 (+1)
THE BIG BANG THEORY – 89 (+3)
ABC
BODY OF PROOF – 27
LAST MAN STANDING – 4 (-3)
THE NEIGHBORS – 3 (-2)
ONCE UPON A TIME – 69 (+3)
MODERN FAMILY – 49 (+2)
Victors’ Village: The Middle, Castle
Basic Cable
COUGAR TOWN – 68 (+3)
PERCEPTION – 20
THE AMERICANS – 38 (+1)
CONTINUUM – 44 (-2)
PSYCH – 39
THE WALKING DEAD – 39 (+2)
AMERICAN HORROR STORY – 29
FALLING SKIES – 18
WAREHOUSE 13 – 24
DOCTOR WHO – 16
BURN NOTICE – 3 (-3)
RIZZOLI & ISLES – 38 (-1)
Premium Cable:
DEXTER – 44
GAME OF THRONES – 64 (+3)
TORCHWOOD – 45
HOMELAND – 58 (+1)
THE NEWSROOM – 44 (+2)
CURB YOUR ENTHUSIASM – 42 (-2)
THE BORGIAS – 18
CALIFORNICATION – 23 (-1)
SPARTACUS – 4 (-3)
EPISODES – 33
80s:
CHEERS – 37
21 JUMP STREET – 41 (+3)
STAR TREK TNG – 32 (+2)
THE COSBY SHOW – 3 (-2)
THE GOLDEN GIRLS – 5 (-3)
M*A*S*H – 11 (-1)
THE A-TEAM – 23 (+1)
90s:
SEINFELD – 30 (-2)
THE X-FILES – 32 (+2)
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER – 65 (+3)
EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND – 25 (-3)
00s:
FIREFLY – 13
SCRUBS – 28 (+3)
PUSHING DAISIES – 12 (-3)
Victors’ Village: Lost
10s:
FRINGE – 68 (+3)
TERRA NOVA – 26 (-2)
ALCATRAZ – 9 (-3)
CHUCK – 52 (+2)
ABC
BODY OF PROOF – 30 (+3)
LAST MAN STANDING – 2 (-2)
THE NEIGHBORS – 0 (-3) How was this show in the last five?? I just don’t get it.
ONCE UPON A TIME – 71 (+2)
MODERN FAMILY – 49
Victors’ Village: The Middle, Castle
CBS
BLUE BLOODS – 14
CSI: NY – 19
THE GOOD WIFE – 24
RULES OF ENGAGEMENT – 14 (-2)
THE MENTALIST – 31 (-1)
CSI – 25
ELEMENTARY – 17
NCIS: LA – 18
PERSON OF INTEREST – 95 (+2)
MIKE & MOLLY – 38 (+3)
NCIS – 38 (-3)
HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER – 25
THE BIG BANG THEORY – 90 (+1)
CW
NIKITA – 59 (-2)
HART OF DIXIE – 17 (+3)
SUPERNATURAL – 72 (-3)
ARROW – 77 (+2)
FOX
THE MINDY PROJECT – 25 (+1)
TOUCH – 45 (+3)
NEW GIRL – 0 (-3) Eliminated
BONES – 26 (+2)
BOB’S BURGERS – 33
THE SIMPSONS – 26 (-1)
THE FOLLOWING – 44 (-2)
Victors’ Village: Raising Hope
OK, third try
NBC
1600 PENN – 13
COMMUNITY – 78 (+1)
30 ROCK – 41 (-3)
GO ON – 45 (+3)
DECEPTION – 11
SMASH – 17
DO NO HARM – 0 (-2) Byebye
PARKS & REC – 57
GRIMM – 20
PARENTHOOD – 31
THE OFFICE – 19 (-1)
CHICAGO FIRE – 26
REVOLUTION – 95 (+2)
Basic Cable
COUGAR TOWN – 69 (+1)
PERCEPTION – 23 (+3)
THE AMERICANS – 35 (-3)
CONTINUUM – 46 (+2)
PSYCH – 39
THE WALKING DEAD – 38 (-1)
AMERICAN HORROR STORY – 29
FALLING SKIES – 18
WAREHOUSE 13 – 24
DOCTOR WHO – 16
BURN NOTICE – 2 (-1)
RIZZOLI & ISLES – 38
Premium Cable:
DEXTER – 44
GAME OF THRONES – 64
TORCHWOOD – 42 (-3)
HOMELAND – 60 (+2)
THE NEWSROOM – 47 (+3)
CURB YOUR ENTHUSIASM – 40 (-2)
THE BORGIAS – 19 (+1)
CALIFORNICATION – 23
SPARTACUS – 3 (-1)
EPISODES – 33
80s:
CHEERS – 35 (-2)
21 JUMP STREET – 41
STAR TREK TNG – 31 (-1)
THE COSBY SHOW – 5 (+2)
THE GOLDEN GIRLS – 6 (+1)
M*A*S*H – 14 (+3)
THE A-TEAM – 20 (-3)
90s:
SEINFELD – 32 (+2)
THE X-FILES – 30 (-2)
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER – 62 (-3)
EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND – 28 (+3)
00s:
FIREFLY – 13
SCRUBS – 28
PUSHING DAISIES – 12
Victors’ Village: Lost
10s:
FRINGE – 66 (-2)
TERRA NOVA – 29 (+3)
ALCATRAZ – 11 (+2)
CHUCK – 49 (-3)
80s:
CHEERS – 38 (+3)
21 JUMP STREET – 38 (-3)
STAR TREK TNG – 29 (-2)
THE COSBY SHOW – 7 (+2)
THE GOLDEN GIRLS – 7 (+1)
M*A*S*H – 14
THE A-TEAM – 19 (-1)
90s:
SEINFELD – 34 (+2)
THE X-FILES – 28 (-2)
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER – 59 (-3)
EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND – 31 (+3)
00s:
FIREFLY – 13
SCRUBS – 31 (+3)
PUSHING DAISIES – 9 (-3)
Victors’ Village: Lost
10s:
FRINGE – 64 (-2)
TERRA NOVA – 26 (-3)
ALCATRAZ – 13 (+2)
CHUCK – 52 (+3)
from Cheers 1.9:
Coach: I’ve been shivering all the way over here.
Diane: Well, Coach, you don’t have a coat on. It’s 30 degrees outside.
Coach: Oh, thank god. I thought I had malaria.
Basic Cable
COUGAR TOWN – 71 (+2)
PERCEPTION – 23
THE AMERICANS – 35
CONTINUUM – 46
PSYCH – 42 (+3)
THE WALKING DEAD – 39 (+1)
AMERICAN HORROR STORY – 29
FALLING SKIES – 17 (-1)
WAREHOUSE 13 – 24
DOCTOR WHO – 13 (-3)
BURN NOTICE – 0 (-2) eliminated
RIZZOLI & ISLES – 38
Premium Cable:
DEXTER – 43 (-1)
GAME OF THRONES – 64
TORCHWOOD – 39 (-3)
HOMELAND – 62 (+2)
THE NEWSROOM – 47
CURB YOUR ENTHUSIASM – 43 (+3)
THE BORGIAS – 19
CALIFORNICATION – 23
SPARTACUS – 1 (-2)
EPISODES – 34 (+1)
from Psych 3.6:
Shawn: Don’t you see what’s happening here, Gus? We are simply pawns in a bitter sibling feud.
Gus: I am nobody’s pawn, Shawn. I’m a Queen.
NBC
1600 PENN – 13
COMMUNITY – 79 (+1)
30 ROCK – 43 (+2)
GO ON – 45
DECEPTION – 8 (-3)
SMASH – 15 (-2)
PARKS & REC – 60 (+3)
GRIMM – 20
PARENTHOOD – 30 (-1)
THE OFFICE – 19
CHICAGO FIRE – 26
REVOLUTION – 95
from this week’s Parks:
Ron Swanson: [on "Pawnee Today" to promote fundraiser gala, taking calls]…Next thing you wanna do is ditch the terrier and get yourself a proper dog. Any dog under 50 pounds is a cat, and cats are pointless. Come to the Gala. Next caller…
FOX
THE MINDY PROJECT – 27 (+2)
TOUCH – 42 (-3)
BONES – 27 (+1)
BOB’S BURGERS – 36 (+3)
THE SIMPSONS – 25 (-1)
THE FOLLOWING – 42 (-2)
Victors’ Village: Raising Hope
from RH 3.17:
Frank: [buying the Chances' van] Now all I need is some good looking friends and a talking dog, and my mystery-solving business is up and running.
CBS
BLUE BLOODS – 13 (-1)
CSI: NY – 19
THE GOOD WIFE – 24
RULES OF ENGAGEMENT – 15 (+1)
THE MENTALIST – 31
CSI – 25
ELEMENTARY – 17
NCIS: LA – 15 (-3)
PERSON OF INTEREST – 95
MIKE & MOLLY – 38
NCIS – 36 (-2)
HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER – 27 (+2)
THE BIG BANG THEORY – 93 (+3)
CW
NIKITA – 57 (-2)
HART OF DIXIE – 19 (+2)
SUPERNATURAL – 75 (+3)
ARROW – 74 (-3)
from SPN 6.18:
Castiel: You only have 24 hours.
Sam: What? Why?
Castiel: Well, the answer to your question can best be expressed as a series of partial differential equations…
Bobby: Yeah, aim lower.
ABC
BODY OF PROOF – 27 (-3)
LAST MAN STANDING – 0 (-2) eliminated
ONCE UPON A TIME – 73 (+2)
MODERN FAMILY – 52 (+3)
Victors’ Village: The Middle, Castle
Out of ABC quotes, so here’s one from Parks on NBC [2.22]:
Leslie: My nana, she used to say the best stuff. “Don’t work yourself into a lather.” “Look where it is and you’ll find it.” “Don’t put me in a Home.” “Tell the truth and shame the devil.” “The devil knows where you’re hiding.” “If you take enough rides with the devil, pretty soon he’s gonna drive.”…She was really into the devil.
Next person to vote on ABC votes just +3 and -3 since we’re down to three shows.
@Nick
No sense in asking why it took so long to eliminated The Neighbors – obviously some of us liked the show (me included – I hardly ever gave it points but I didn’t take any away). We all have different tastes…I for one scratch my head at how some voters here really think The A Team, Star Trek TNG and 21 Jump Street can maybe win and represent the favorite show of a DECADE. Kid stuff, IMO. But to each his/her own.
@Rebecca: You forget, Cheers is still very much in the running. I bet it’ll win again easily. We’ve all got game trends to wonder about. For instance, I’m shocked that H50′s been eliminated almost in last place twice in a row.
ABC
BODY OF PROOF – 24 (-3)
ONCE UPON A TIME – 73
MODERN FAMILY – 55 (+3)
Victors’ Village: The Middle, Castle