Bubble Watch: Why 'Last Man Standing' Is Still On The Bubble & 'Beauty and the Beast' Is Likely to Be Canceled + Format Change

Categories: Bubble Watch

Written By

March 17th, 2013


When it comes to bubble status, like the Renew/Cancel Index we're focusing on the likelihood that a show will be renewed **for next season** (2013-14).  Certain shows are toss-ups where based on the ratings, the renewal decisions could go either way and not be surprising.

Here, “canceled” is used interchangeably with “won’t be renewed for next season” and is not meant to imply a show will be yanked off the schedule in the current season though obviously the two outcomes are not mutually exclusive. The semantics police and lawyers should feel free to break out the handcuffs and plead their cases in the comments. 

This Isn't The Renew/Cancel Index

Though the basic methodology is the same (intra-network relative ranking of shows by adults 18-49 ),unlike the Renew/Cancel Index which predicts what would happen if the season ended now, Bubble Watch prognosticates about what will happen by May. The two are still usually closely aligned, and almost certainly very closely aligned towards the end of the season.

Beauty and the Beast & The Carrie Diaries

I’ve downgraded Beauty and the Beast to likely cancellation. I’ve left The Carrie Diaries on the bubble, but it’s by the slimmest of margins and I was tempted to downgrade it too. I understand Bill’s and others' thinking that if you’re not sure the CW would cancel both of those shows (or even either of them) due to need for shows on next season’s schedule, that relative to each other which one stays and which one goes definitely seems like a tossup. But while lead-in and retention are rarely a predictive factor in renewals, I think they matter in this case and in ways that aren't favorable at all for Beauty and the Beast.

It's true that The Carrie Diaries gets the lead-in from CW affiliates syndicated programming, but that's not been nearly as good as the cover The Vampire Diaries provides Beauty and the Beast. And while with the better lead-in Beauty and the Beast has recently outperformed The Carrie Diaries with adults 18-49, with the women 18-34 both shows presumably target, The Carrie Diaries is ahead in recent episodes.

I’m pretty sure CW will cancel one of the two. I’m not as certain that they will cancel both, but I still don't love the chances for either show, I just like The Carrie Diaries a teeny tiny bit more. Even with the lament "but The Carrie Diaries doesn't have to face off against Grey's Anatomy and Beauty and the Beast does!" I still like Carrie's prospects just a bit better.

At this point it doesn't seem likely that I'll upgrade Beauty and the Beast before the season ends, but the chances I'll downgrade The Carrie Diaries to likely cancellation remain high.

Last Man Standing & Malibu Country

Along with many readers, Bill made a compelling case for upgrading Last Man Standing to likely renewal. I won’t be surprised by that outcome, but in a world where success possibly equals doing worse than reruns of Shark Tank, and no recent history on ABC to use as a guideline (or recent history* with any Friday 30 minute sitcoms being renewed on  any broadcast network) I still shrug my shoulders and think “I don’t know.” So I went the other way on this one, I left Last Man Standing on the bubble and downgraded the noticeably worse performer Malibu Country to likely cancellation.

*If you think “Family Matters, Boy Meets World and others thrived on Friday!” counts as  recent history I am defining “recent” much differently than you!

New Format

Shortly after posting last week’s Bubble Watch, I changed the table format to get rid of the distinction between likely and certain. For now, I’m sticking with the approach, though I have (hopefully) improved some of the terminology to be less confusing than what I used last week.  Gone are the “likely” and “certain” distinctions. All that remains are “renewed” and “canceled” predictions.  I still have grouped the shows that have already been canceled or renewed separately and have attempted to label things in such a way that it’s quite clear what’s already been decided and what are predictions. Update: I have changed the table to improve readability further based on a suggestion from commenter JulieDawn.

The new presentation format doesn't mean all the renewal predictions are as likely as each other, or all the cancellation predictions. Of course I don't think The Neighbors' chances* are as good as Modern Family's. Same for Red Widow (a certain cancellation) and Malibu Country (a likely cancellation). Both appear the same on the table with a "canceled" prediction, but I don't view their prospects the same. But I still think Modern Family & The Neighbors will be renewed and that Red Widow and Malibu Country will be canceled so despite levels of likelihood, I don't think the distinctions matter much as far as the table goes. We'll see.

*"The Neighbors barely did better on a Wednesday than Last Man Standing did on Friday, how can you not upgrade Last Man Standing!? At least you should downgrade The Neighbors!!!" If you're one of those people, let's just say that when ABC airs 5 programs on a Wednesday and four of them are repeats with The Neighbors being the only one that isn't, I don't make too much of the ratings.

Note: only scripted shows that have aired at least one episode this season are in the table below.

Show Network Status
666 Park Avenue ABC Canceled
Don't Trust the B---- in Apartment 23 ABC Canceled
Last Resort ABC Canceled
Private Practice ABC Final Season Finished
Zero Hour ABC Canceled
Made in Jersey CBS Canceled
Partners CBS Canceled
90210 CW Canceled/Final Season
Emily Owens, M.D. CW Canceled
Gossip Girl CW Final Season Finished
Ben and Kate Fox Canceled
Fringe Fox Final Season Finished
The Mob Doctor Fox Canceled
30 Rock NBC Final Season Finished
Animal Practice NBC Canceled
Do No Harm NBC Canceled
Office, The NBC Final Season
Big Bang Theory, The CBS Renewed
How I Met Your Mother CBS Renewed
NCIS CBS Renewed
Arrow CW Renewed
Supernatural CW Renewed
Vampire Diaries, The CW Renewed
American Dad Fox Renewed
Bob's Burgers Fox Renewed
Bones Fox Renewed
Family Guy Fox Renewed
Following, The Fox Renewed
Mindy Project, The Fox Renewed
New Girl Fox Renewed
Raising Hope Fox Renewed
The Simpsons Fox Renewed
Malibu Country ABC Cancellation Predicted
Red Widow ABC Cancellation Predicted
Body of Proof ABC Cancellation Predicted
Happy Endings ABC Cancellation Predicted
CSI: NY CBS Cancellation Predicted
Golden Boy CBS Cancellation Predicted
Vegas CBS Cancellation Predicted
Beauty and the Beast CW Cancellation Predicted
Cult CW Cancellation Predicted
Touch Fox Cancellation Predicted
Cleveland Show, The Fox Cancellation Predicted
1600 Penn NBC Cancellation Predicted
Guys with Kids NBC Cancellation Predicted
Up All Night NBC Cancellation Predicted
Deception NBC Cancellation Predicted
The New Normal NBC Cancellation Predicted
Smash NBC Whoops, should've been moved to canceled
Last Man Standing ABC On The Bubble
Good Wife, The CBS On The Bubble
Mentalist, The CBS On The Bubble
Rules of Engagement CBS On The Bubble
Carrie Diaries, The CW On The Bubble
Community NBC On The Bubble
Go On NBC On The Bubble
Whitney NBC On The Bubble
Castle ABC Renewal Predicted
Neighbors, The ABC Renewal Predicted
Revenge ABC Renewal Predicted
Suburgatory ABC Renewal Predicted
Grey's Anatomy ABC Renewal Predicted
Middle, The ABC Renewal Predicted
Modern Family ABC Renewal Predicted
Nashville ABC Renewal Predicted
Once Upon a Time ABC Renewal Predicted
Scandal ABC Renewal Predicted
Elementary CBS Renewal Predicted
Hawaii Five-0 CBS Renewal Predicted
2 Broke Girls CBS Renewal Predicted
Blue Bloods CBS Renewal Predicted
Criminal Minds CBS Renewal Predicted
CSI CBS Renewal Predicted
Mike & Molly CBS Renewal Predicted
NCIS: Los Angeles CBS Renewal Predicted
Person of Interest CBS Renewal Predicted
Two and a Half Men CBS Renewal Predicted
Hart of Dixie CW Renewal Predicted
Nikita CW Renewal Predicted
Glee Fox Renewal Predicted
Law & Order: SVU NBC Renewal Predicted
Parks & Recreation NBC Renewal Predicted
Chicago Fire NBC Renewal Predicted
Grimm NBC Renewal Predicted
Parenthood NBC Renewal Predicted
Revolution NBC Renewal Predicted


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
  • Hepha

    I don’t really appreciate the “Cancellation Predicted” standing next to “CSI NY”, but I’m less and less convinced that it will have a season 10, though I want it so bad !

  • MissJo

    I don’t like the new format. The old one was better.

  • cadburyeasteregg

    Why do people keep defending Deception? It boggles the mind. If you have enough sense, the killer and father plot were way too obvious.

  • Just Desserts

    Hahahahhaha. The Neighbors is getting renewed!!!! :) :) :)

    Happy St. Paddy’s!

  • sasha

    The Cw doesnt just look at ratings, it looks at online and socially. BATB does better than TCD in that format and the ratings. With a show pulling in 0.4 and with barely 1 mill viewers. I dont see TCD being renewed over BATB.

  • Danak

    Robert, I like the latest changes to the table. It comes across pretty clear to me. I don’t think we really need all the distinctions of likely and what not. Predicted (canceled or renewed) and On the Bubble work for me and it’s probably a lot simpler for you.

  • Brandy

    @KS CD is a first season show that had/has a lot of promotion and switched timeslots so it would have a higher rated leadin from local syndicated stuff getting multiple 0.4s even before DST.CW has NEVER renewed a first season show with those ratings before-Ringer and Hellcats are two examples.Also, CW is moving away from teen dramas/soaps to teen genre scifi fantasy type shows.HoD didn’t help Cult so I doubt it’d doubt it would CD next season if CD is already pulling 0.4s.CD is too far away from syndication. I agree that BATB will Likley be cancelled but it still has a slim shot at renwal because it does well online, in DVr & is cheap to make & sold well internationally and is a genre show, the direction CW is heading and simply for the fact that with 90210,Cult, GG EOMD,,LA Complex, and CD most Likley cancelled they may not be able to afford to cancel it ,then theres OHSit and the other reality shows to deal with too.It will move though as Originals will take its spot if Beauty somehow gets renewed and yes it will do worse elsewhere. CD might have better retention from a not as good leadin as BaTB but it’s still poorly.Now, I’d agree with you if CD and Beauty both maintained 0.6-0.7 or Beauty fell further but that’s not happened.

  • Matt

    ABC has a GREAT friday lineup. Shark Tank is Friday’s #1 show, and it almost always wins the night with help from its scripted comedies. 5-7 Million viewers for these 3 shows is good, especially for Friday when the average for viewers on other networks ranges from 1-4 Million (except CBS).
    LMS and MC are a GREAT pair together, so if one goes, so should the other.

    The scheduling advisors at ABC actually hit it right with Friday! 2 comedies, 1 reality, and a new program to wrap up the night. LMS is male-geared, and MC is slightly female-geared. Plus, these 2 shows have big names to go along with them, LMS with Tim Allen and Nancy Travis, and MC with Reba McEntire, Lily Tomlin, and Sara Rue, which is why ABC would be losing something big if they cancelled one of these.

    Both of these shows also average better in viewers than Suburgatory and The Neighbors on a weekly basis – and they air on FRIDAY!

    LMS also occasionally will match Blue Bloods in the demo.

    They also do great in DVR Playback – both adding more than 2 million each time – and they air on FRIDAY.

  • R E Cunningham

    I think ABC would be foolish to drop Malibu Country. It was put on Friday night,not the best tv night,and it does have a viewing audience. It is a good show, full of humor, and the cast works well together. I hope they leave it alone and let all of us that like it, enjoy it. it is better than all of the reality shows and the rest of the mess that is on tv.

  • Kavyn

    I think The Carrie Diaries should have been put for likely cancellation while BATB should have stayed on the bubble. I think both shows will be cancelled, however if you’re comparing the two I do think BATB has a slight edge since it can be paired with Nikita on Fridays at 9pm. TCD won’t do any better in a different time slot and is currently getting lower ratings than BATB (even though BATB does have TVD as a lead in).

    I think many are comparing the TCD v BATB race with last year’s HOD v TSC race, but I think both shows are doing much worse to even make the comparison. The only edge TCD has right now is the Sex and the City thing, and maybe they would renew it to instill confidence in SATC fans to watch it, but I really don’t see it making a difference next season whatsoever.


    “Deception” is good.

  • Lalya

    Even though TCD is doing a little better than BATB (consider to BATB ratings as after a lead-in show), I think BATB is the one to get renewed because it have a lot of success online, the fans insanely want it to be renewed and it’s something that you can’t miss.

  • Glue

    Is ABC not going to air the remaining Apartment 23 episodes?

  • Moose

    Perhaps it is just me, but that red print is really hard on the eyes. I am not complaining, just making an observation.

  • Ravenrei

    I’m basically fine with the new format, though I would leave the confirmed renewals at the bottom. It makes sense to keep cancellations with cancellations and renewals with renewals. Plus, then the chart as a whole flows from one end of the possibilities to the other.

  • http://tvbythenumbers.com Robert Seidman

    Smash should’ve been moved to already canceled. I’m not at my computer right now so can’t replace the table, but have updated its status.

  • Funeral Dinner

    Presumably if 0.5 and 0.4’s got all past CW shows cancelled, why will it be any different for Beauty & the Beast or Carrie Diaries?

  • Jonay

    Has CBS canceled Dogs in the city???

  • John A

    Weird that CBS hasnt renewed shows like 2 Broke Girls POI NCIS LA Blue Bloods and H50 the sure thing renewels. Older shows like CSI 2 half men and Criminal Minds be at Contract negotiations.

  • Danak

    Robert, I would leave Smash where it is as it’s still going to show the rest of its season, only on Saturday and the network hasn’t officially announced a cancellation yet. Yes, I know it’s 99.999% certain that NBC won’t renew it for next season but labeling it as canceled would imply it was being yanked before the end of the season. If you still want to label it as canceled, I suggest including something that says the rest of season will be still be shown.

© 2015 Tribune Digital Ventures