FOX had the No. 1 show on broadcast TV without the word “Football” in it — “Empire” — in 2015-16. What it did not have this season was much in the way of successful first-year shows to jumpstart the post-“American Idol” rebuilding process.

Even in a year when the network knew it had a looming schedule hole to fill, the track record for new shows this season was not strong. Here’s the breakdown of the network’s 10 first-year scripted series.

See also: Failure factor: How bad was 2015-16 for new shows?

Renewed: 3

Dramas “Lucifer” and “Rosewood” were decent performers for the network, each drawing slightly above FOX’s scripted series average for the season: “Lucifer” averaged a same-day 1.47 rating in adults 18-49, and “Rosewood” a 1.35 (the network average for scripted shows, not counting “The X-Files,” was 1.26). Neither one was ever really in danger, particularly with the need to fill the “Idol” space in 2016-17.

“Scream Queens” didn’t do as well in the same-day averages (1.06 in 18-49) but made up some ground with delayed viewing (it moved ahead of “Rosewood,” for instance, in Live +3). That, plus the fact that it’s a shorter-run show from Ryan Murphy, who has deep ties to FOX and its sister studio, make its renewal not much a surprise either.

Canceled: 6

FOX had a particularly rough year with its comedies, with none of its four freshman half- hour series (“Bordertown,” “Cooper Barrett’s Guide to Surviving Life,” “Grandfathered” and “The Grinder”) making it to a second season. Ouch.

Dramas “Minority Report” and “Second Chance” never got much of a foothold. “Minority Report” had its order cut and bowed out quietly in the fall, while “Second Chance” was shipped to Fridays after a few outings. They ended the season as FOX’s two lowest-rated scripted shows.

TBD: 1

The network hasn’t made a decision yet on “Houdini & Doyle,” which is averaging a 0.6 same-day rating in adults 18-49.

Failure rate

Currently/best case: 60 percent. Worst case: 70 percent.

Posted by:Rick Porter

Rick Porter has been covering TV since the days when networks sent screeners on VHS, one of which was a teaser for the first season of "American Idol." He's left-handed, makes a very solid grilled cheese and has been editor of TV by the Numbers since October 2015. He lives in Austin.

  • Failure factor: How bad was the 2015-16 TV season for new shows? – TV By The Numbers by

    […] CBS | The CW | FOX | […]


blog comments powered by Disqus